| Robert James Carroll (1838 - 1913) |
|
| Sarah Flemming (1842 - 1909) |
| Patrick M. Shay | Jemima Carroll |
| b. Feb 1851, Massachusetts d. bur. |
b. 26 Jun 1874, Boone, Illinois d. 4 Jul 1934, Portland, Multnomah, Oregon bur. |
| spouses: 1, 2 |
| Helen Shay Frances Shay |