This picture was submitted by Tami (DeRossett) Moorcroft. Here are her comments on the picture:
"Written on the back of the photo: Standing in back: ______, Jim Shaner, Clarence Birley, _____, Pete Livingston, ___, ___, ____, ____, Neil McMurry; Kneeling in front: Bennie Belcher, ___, Percy Birley, Tom Shaner, Tate Berry. ____. Maybe some one can fill in the blanks.....This must be in the late 40 or early 50's."
In an email from 31 Jan 2006, Carole Thomas Wiskirken identified the 8th man in the back row (left to right) to be her uncle, Arthur Rosander.
In an email from 4 May 2016, Lorene Livingstone Winston wrote: "I recognize my Uncle Charley right away. He is Charles Livingstone, the tallest guy in the back row with his hat pitched back a bit. The man next to him is identified as a Livingstone but I think that is in error. I never heard of a Pete Livingstone and I think he is misidentified."